Poll: Who Would Win In A Fight?

10 comments

1. 

   Tirian / February 8, 2015

   *SPOILER*

   Sara Oakheart or Amarthiel? Because by the period of the story that we’re in, they’re one and the same, and Amarthiel could beat all the others (even a hungry hobbit!) hands down…

   Reply
2. 

   Teriadwyn / February 8, 2015

   Are there really any ‘winners’ in this list? A hobbit is only winning if he or she is full of pie.

   Reply
3. 

   bruthvo / February 8, 2015

   Obviously Lalia would win, think of the armour she could fashion out of all of her mithril coins! Or she could port right behind you with them and trap you in cloak!

   Reply
4. 

   timhedden / February 8, 2015

   I chose Sara Oakheart. She incapacitates with slow paced boredom.

   Reply
5. 

   Goblinbane / February 9, 2015

   If you show a pie to a hungry hobbit he is unbeatable for sure. None wizard and warrior is more powerful, then hobbit trying to get a pie. Even Balrog and Sauron would run seeing that hobbit.

   Reply
6. 

   Barnabras / February 9, 2015

   Without a doubt it’s Grima. He killed Saruman, a Maia for crying out load! No one else on this list did that, in fact the only other in the third age was Gandalf.

   Reply
   • 

     Goblinbane / February 9, 2015

     Well it was Maia deprived of all his powers except voice, if I remember correctly 🙂

     Reply
     • 

       Barnabras / February 12, 2015

       A Maia is a Maia. And by the way, didn’t Saruman imply that Grima ate a hobbit! Hungry hobbit Wormtongue will eat you!!

7. 

   Zyngor / February 9, 2015

   Rook is by far the most imaginative person on this list – anyone who believes they are a powerful wizard, and will be willing to put that to the test (only to reappear later with more crazy schemes) has something going for them. We need more Rook in the game!

   Reply
8. 

   scoedt / February 21, 2015

   Sara won. The other contestants grew old and died while waiting for her to walk to the sparing circle.

   Reply